Umm ummmm ummm. I cannot decide. It's a tossup between S1 and S3.

S1 makes me nostalgic because I never watched it on TV, I watched it for the very first time on those DVDs kept that pretty box with pretty pretty Brian smirking at me every time I went to get the next DVD. So it wins for nostalgia plus it's v. pretty and the characters are so in-character omg! It's probably the most in-character cover of all.

The S3 cover is also in-character for that season with Brian all emo and v.v.v.v.pretty and it's a good thing that box is shiny so we can wipe off the drool kthnx.

The S5 cover makes me cry from the hideousness. S4 is okay. The orgy is nice although I'm not such a fan of the photoshopping. S2 is nice but it's like playing "one of these things is not like the others" - I'll never understand why they were so inconsistent with the box art! Most series' season sets all look alike but QAF is all... huh? Matching sets wha? A box like the Highlander one wouldn't even work for us because S4 is the wrong size. :[

Anyway, I kinda like this new QAF box - it's simple and pretty... nowhere near as pretty as S3 but not bad. Those individual boxes are bad though, they look like cheap knock-offs of a real DVD set OMG. Back away, photoshop person, back away.